BPA's Executive Director Greg Galer on How Boston's Next Mayor Can Protect the City's Built History
This piece was originally published on the Historic Boston, Inc. website.
Will the next Mayor recognize that prioritizing preservation benefits Boston and Bostonians?
Those of us who have daily interactions with City policy, agencies, and staff know that while the Mayor isn’t personally involved in every decision that comes out of Boston government, the Mayor certainly sets a tone that permeates the entirety of the city’s operation. The “Fifth Floor” (where the Mayor’s Office, as well as the offices of City Councilors, reside) exists in physical reality and in metaphor. When someone says “It came from the Fifth Floor,” everyone knows it’s something the Mayor wants.
Of course, the impact and frequency of a statement like that varies by mayor. Some were actively involved, down in the weeds, and nothing of consequence would move very far without a nod from the Mayor’s office. In other administrations, the control wasn’t so tight. Regardless, the messaging that comes from the Fifth Floor as far as priorities, goals, and third-rail issues is generally well-known to City Hall staff. When, for example, Mayor Walsh made it clear that building housing was a priority, that permeated all decision-making. Getting the number of new housing units up was primary. However, even though the rehabilitation and adaptive use of historic buildings for affordable housing is a proven effective tool, historic preservation was not a priority of the last administration. That was frustrating. We hope that our next Mayor recognizes the multifaceted benefits of our historic resources.
On housing, affordability, environmental, labor, resiliency, economic, and cultural grounds, a stronger emphasis of city government on preserving and creatively using the city’s historic resources benefits all Bostonians. With 78% of the city built before World War II, there is simply no way the city can meet its climate goals without programs that support our existing buildings, particularly residential properties in the neighborhoods. Residents from East Boston to West Roxbury are seeing the negative impacts on their neighborhoods of a disease of demolitions, most based on a myopic and inaccurate belief that new construction is always best. The fact is, while certainly at times demolition and new construction makes sense, it is often not the best path to support environmental goals, provide more jobs, or create more affordable housing. Rehabilitating and creatively using historic resources (many times in conjunction with new) will often drive the best result for Bostonians.
Studies abound demonstrating that adaptation of historic properties for affordable housing is far more cost-effective, particularly given robust programs such as the state and federal Rehabilitation Tax Credit which can reduce construction costs by up to 40%. Paired with the Low-Income Historical Tax Credit the cost to build each unit of affordable housing can be far less than ground up construction. Never mind the environmental benefits of not demolishing existing buildings. Reports such as Older, Smaller, Better demonstrate that established neighborhoods with a mix of older, smaller buildings perform better than districts with larger, newer structures when tested against a range of economic, social, and environmental outcome measures.
So, what are we hoping to hear from the candidates looking to take that all-important seat on the Fifth Floor?
The Mayor should be clear that the multi-faceted benefits of historic preservation are a priority at the highest level of the City. They should make a specific statement that by supporting efforts to preserve and invest in historic resources of all types in all neighborhoods, City staff will be advancing the Mayor’s economic, social, environmental, and cultural goals. Additionally, it’s important that the Mayor provide clarity that preservation isn’t about freezing the city in time and stopping development, it’s about being more thoughtful in how the city grows and evolves, to support change that doesn’t blindly erase our past but better integrates it into our future.
The Mayor should recognize that our current policies, procedures, and regulations regarding historic preservation are out-of-date, of limited impact, and inequitable. The strongest way to assure historic areas of the city are preserved from rampant demolition and soulless new construction is to create a Landmark District. We haven’t had a new District established since 2009. Additionally, the places that hold stories we highlight today are more difficult to protect with our existing process. Many were not designed by famous architects, don’t survive to today unaltered, and are often connected to histories less well documented. Some of the oldest buildings in the city were only recently identified, and some were just as quickly demolished! If you don’t identify it you can’t preserve it. It’s as simple as that, and our surveys identifying the city’s historic resources are largely incomplete and out-of-date. Our understanding of what is historic, whose history places represent, and what should be preserved is inadequate. This lack of information is unfair to residents, neighborhoods, property owners, and developers. The new mayor must make investing in a comprehensive survey of historic resources a priority immediately. It will be a multi-year, significant investment but will pay clear dividends in protection of resources and predictability for the development community, city planners, and residents.
The time has come for a mayor who will support reevaluation of the entire development review process – both Article 80 Large Project Review and Small Project Review. The process is cumbersome to residents and the real estate development community, and many feel it is ineffective on both sides. Impact Advisory Groups, for example, provide some level of “community” input, but their selection and representation of resident desires are unclear. (Just take the recent debate over saving Amrheins in South Boston, where the IAG strongly pushed for its demolition but the broader Southie community wanted it preserved.)
Of course, this leads to the broader question if the current BPDA structure is best serving the city’s needs. Honest assessment is needed to assure that economic power of growth and development of the city is maximized to best serve the residents of Boston past, present, and future. While we often support thoughtful development and growth, we also warn of “killing the goose that lays the golden egg,” that gold being the unique historic character that drives so many residents, businesses, and tourists to the city. The creative energy that powers Boston rests upon walls, foundations (and sensitive wooden pilings), and character century’s old. When they are lost, they are lost forever.
We are looking for a mayor who recognizes that demolition is rampant across the city. The unquestioned belief that newer is better, that older buildings should be removed to the landfill unless something or someone of regional or national historic importance happened there, and that the burden of proof should lay in the under-sourced Boston Landmarks Commission is simply a poorly framed and inaccurate representation of reality. The process needs to be changed. Article 85, our Demolition Delay Bylaw, which we’ve been pushing to modify or wholly replace for over a decade, seems to be finally finding some activity to do so in City Hall. This needs to be recognized as not simply a historic preservation issue. Demolition is certainly part of the evolution of cities. We are not looking to stop that. We want the burden of proof to be placed on those proposing demolition. They should have to demonstrate why demolition is better for the city. Demolition of the average single family house produces roughly the same amount of waste as the average person does in their entire lifetime. Never mind the carbon impact of demolition of larger, commercial properties. When a building must come down the City should insist it be deconstructed and materials re-used rather than go to the landfill. Additionally, many of the demolitions in historic neighborhoods replace naturally affordable housing in historic buildings. Instead, we get several units of market-rate housing, remove open space, and accelerate the homogenization of our neighborhoods. The current process is ineffective. Residents and we are simply tired of a process that doesn’t work.
Our new Mayor must recognize that demolition isn’t simply occurring by bulldozers and wrecking crews. Demolition by neglect and deterioration to the point of no return is actively destroying historic resources and threatening the health and safety of residents. Properties such as the Alley-Eblana Brewery, fallow in Mission Hill for decades, Mission Church buildings, or the Villa Victoria Church in the South End are just a few examples of this problem. A minimum maintenance ordinance is badly needed as well as its specific listing as a trigger for a revised Demolition Delay bylaw.
Funding for historic preservation has long been a problem in Boston. However, a Mayor who recognizes the vast benefits of historic resources should also see that investment in historic places pays huge dividends. While we are pleased that our advocacy for an increase in the Boston Landmarks Commission was successful with more funding, that office remains inadequately staffed to manage the work they should be doing. The BLC should have the ability to be pro-active rather than their current challenge to even be re-active. They should be out in the neighborhoods and with developers BEFORE proposals are filed. The BLC should be more integrated into the early part of the development process, so they can be more impactful in the forward-thinking aspects of city evolution.
We need a Mayor who recognizes that priority funding for historic resources in all aspects is a valuable investment in the city’s future. Currently historic resources are starved for funding, generally getting the lowest priority throughout the city’s funding stream. A great example of this is how the funds of the Community Preservation Act are distributed. Three funding areas: affordable housing, open space/parks, and historic preservation areas are equivalent by the state enabling legislation and the creation of Boston’s CPA. While both affordable housing and open space already have existing capital budgets in the City, historic preservation does not. Yet the focus of this program to date has largely been on affordable housing where CPA funds are far less impactful than they are for preservation projects. This is simply wrong. We need a Mayor who recognizes that CPA should be doing a better job supporting our much-needed historic resources. The Legacy Fund for Boston is another funding mechanism for which we advocated. The Mayor should insist that development projects that negatively impact historic resources make significant contributions.
Finally, we need a mayor who sees as important the re-examination of the Boston Landmarks Commission and its role in the city management and governance process. Boston so often touts itself as historic. Mayors talk about “our historic city,” but we’ve seen few support this rhetoric with action. Just look at the backlog of nearly 90 City Landmarks that remain in a “pending” status due to the inability of the BLC to complete the process. Boston was once a national leader in this work, but we’ve fallen behind. With BLC often the last to know about proposals, seeing development proposals for review after most every other agency has approved, and our one historic agency given little true role in impacting how the city moves forward, how can we expect to be leaders as we should be?
We hope our next mayor truly sees and supports “our historic city” with action. If not, we will lose our unique edge that benefits residents and brings investor and tourism dollars and is the very reason so many Bostonians love our city. Historic places don’t exist with us today due to indifference. They require investment and active efforts to assure they remain integral aspects of our lives. We can thank previous generations for stewarding the historic places we have. Let’s not give opportunity for those who come behind us to criticize us for dropping the ball. Let us be a national leader in historic preservation as we once were, not the middle of the pack where we currently seem to be.
Recent
Several new Landmarks have been designated in Boston. Even more are pending approval and awaiting community feedback and support.
“Love is showing the important things that they matter.” A Landmark Love quote from the Frederick Middle School.
Update: February 29, 2024
The Boston Preservation Alliance has submitted a letter to the Wu Administration.
Each year the Boston Preservation Alliance presents the Preservation Achievement Awards to recognize a group of exemplary historic preservation projects or activities in Boston.
A Visual Guide to “Barbitecture” and Real-life Doll Houses
Written by: Sara Brown
Alliance Executive Director Alison Frazee received a call last night from Mike Firestone, the City’s Chief of Policy, informing her that the Landmarks Commission has been…
May is National Preservation Month which gives us a perfect excuse to show off our beloved historic city.
May is National Preservation Month which gives us a perfect excuse to show off our beloved historic city.
On behalf of the Boston Preservation Alliance and Boston’s preservation community, we would like to thank Councilor Kenzie Bok for her dedication to our city’s historic resources.
The Codman Award for lifetime achievement, named for John Codman who established Boston’s first historic district (Beacon Hill) in 1955, recognizes outstanding and career-long…
Thank you for helping us redefine preservation. Architecture is the surface of a city, but our history is deeper than a facade. It is the people, residents, and visitors that make Boston…
The leaves have been shaken off the trees, there is a chill in the air, and the sun sets just after 4 pm–that’s right, it’s nearly winter in New England and the gift-giving…
Written by Anan Shen. This is the first of a series of short stories about the West End.
As an advocacy organization for historic preservation, the Alliance often advocates to save historic buildings because of their stunning architecture or articulated streetscape.
Written and researched by Dan Bailey.
All photos by Dan Bailey and Matthew Dickey.
Stories about our neighborhoods are often told by adults for adults. But what landmarks and businesses define our neighborhoods through the eyes of the next generation?
Thousands and thousands of buildings line Boston’s streets. But one house is different from all the rest. It takes a bit of determination to find it.
Photos by Peter Vanderwarker.
A Weekend Photo Workshop with Peter Vanderwarker, Sept. 16-18
May is National Preservation Month which gives us a perfect excuse to show off our beloved historic city.
On May 1, 2022, Boston celebrated the 200th anniversary of incorporation as a city at the Old South Meeting House.
Valentine’s Day is approaching and that means only one thing—it’s time to dust off those markers and share some love (Heart Bombs) for old buildings! What are heart bombs?
In a little triangle just south of Andrew Station, Polish and American flags fly in pairs. The air wafts with the smell of freshly fried dough.
Our Most-Watched Advocacy Projects of 2021 Are Below, But First…
The Alliance relies on generous supporters like you to continue our work in promoting, preserving,…
The Alliance has been utilizing every opportunity to further our goals of historic preservation advocacy and telling the fuller story of Boston’s past. Below are a few of our 2021…
Thursday, December 2, 10:00-11:00 am.
The Boston Preservation Alliance is Boston’s primary, non-profit advocacy organization that protects and promotes the use of historic buildings and landscapes in all of Boston’s…
Turn on your favorite sea shanty and prepare for the water. The Young Advisors are bringing their annual Libations for Preservation event to the sea!
Written by Ava Yokanovich
Photos by Ava Yokanovich
Interview with Angela Ward Hyatt
Photos courtesy of Angela Ward Hyatt
Before and after photos below!
Memories from former South End residents Judith Nee and Isabel O’Hara
Images from Neil Kadey and Judith Nee
Written by Judith Nee and Ava Yokanovich
Written by Mackenzie Barrall and Corinne Muller. Photos by Matthew Dickey.
Originally published July 2020. Updated July 2021.
The Alliance works closely with the Boston Landmarks Commission (BLC), which resides within the Environment Department at the City, to further preservation efforts in Boston.
Written by Mackenzie Barrall
Photos by Ava Yokanovich
Written by Ava Yokanovich
Images taken by Ava Yokanovich along the Southwest Corridor Path near Titus Sparrow Park
Since 1988, the National Trust has used its list of America’s 11 Most Endangered Historic Places…
Since 1988, the National Trust has used its list of America’s 11 Most Endangered Historic Places…
Since 1988, the National Trust has used its list of America’s 11 Most Endangered Historic Places…
Written by Jeanne Pelletier, Preservation Advisor to the Campaign for the Ayer Mansion, Inc.
There are untold stories in Boston being lost and we need your help to save them.
Save-The-Date
When: March 25
Time: 6 pm via Zoom
Featuring: Brent Leggs
This event is generously supported by the Nolan-Miller Fund
Corita Kent (1918–1986)
Artist, Educator, Advocate for Social Justice
Written by: Vicki Adjami
When: March 4
Time: 10 AM
Where: On Zoom
How: Register below to receive a zoom link
The Boston Preservation Alliance and the Young Advisors present:
Preservation Chatter 2020
Thursday, November 19
6 — 7 PM
David Rodrigues is the Manager of Facilities and Preservation at
Preservation takes many forms and requires many hands.
Boston Preservation Alliance stands united with the voices decrying the murder of George Floyd and the long-standing history of racism this tragedy demonstrates.
The Boston Preservation Alliance offers internships to graduate and undergraduate students to help train the next generation of preservationists by providing hands-on experience in…
Let’s come together to create a wave of generosity for the organizations that help Boston thrive.
Have a preservation question? Want to hear updates about any of the preservation projects we’re monitoring?
An Environment Notification Form (ENF) has been filed with the Massachusetts Environmental Policy Act (MEPA) Office.
May is National Preservation Month which gives us a perfect excuse to show off our beloved historic city.
Written by Alison Frazee, Assistant Director, Boston Preservation Alliance.
…Join us for our Annual Meeting of Members
When: Postponed. New date is TBD
In light of concerns with COVID-19, we have postponed several of our upcoming events.
Is there a preservationist in your life? Or maybe you love architecture, history, and unique Boston stories as much as we do. If either of these is the case, then this is THE gift guide…
With the proposed redevelopment of the Hurley Building, we thought this is a good time…
Preservation advocates are imploring Massachusetts General Hospital to reconfigure its expansion plans to avoid demolition of three historic West End buildings, reports Dan Murphy of the…
By Isabella Labbe
August 6, 2019. Updated March 2023.
The Boston Preservation Alliance Board of Young Advisors presents:
Libations for Preservation
When:
Wednesday, July 24, 2019…
Karen McFeaters is a Boston-based painter whose work features locations around the city that highlight…
Roger Webb was the founder of the Architectural Heritage Foundation and…
Save the date for Beer + Mortar, a walking tour through Dorchester and Roxbury led by Matthew Dickey of the Alliance and HBI.…
The City of Boston invites you to a Community Meeting on the Northern Ave Bridge
Monday, June 3, 2019
Neighborhoods are living things. They evolve to the changing needs of their inhabitants. Rural farms become streetcar suburbs. Carriage lanes become roads. Thriving businesses fade.
In partnership with Massachusetts Historical Society and Fenway Alliance.
The state gets a $98M cut of GE’s sale of its property in Fort Point. Where should that money go?
May is National Preservation Month which gives us a perfect excuse to show off our beloved historic city.
Advocacy needed to OPPOSE a rule change to undercut the National Register of Historic Places
Please join us for our Annual Meeting | Registration is closed, but walk-ins welcome!
Boston Design Week Event
Boston Design Week March 27-April 7 2019
The Alliance’s Young Advisor’s Board is seeking new board members for 2019!
The Boston Preservation Alliance is now accepting nominations for our 2019 Preservation Achievement Awards!
The closing of Durgin Park (1827) following upon Jacob Wirth (1868) last year reminds us that Boston’s unique character comes from more than just architecture.
“An icon of the Boston skyline was very nearly protected against the city’s current rapacious development culture- but then the mayor stepped in.”
“An icon of the Boston skyline was very nearly protected against the city’s current rapacious development culture- but then the mayor stepped in.”
Mayor Walsh, Citgo, Related Beal (the developer of the site), and Boston University release a statement:
Mayor Walsh, Citgo, Related Beal (the developer of the site), and Boston University release a statement:
The City of Boston invites you to a
Community Meeting on the Northern Ave Bridge
The Young Advisors is a board of developing professionals whose role is to expand and amplify the Alliance’s mission of protecting places, promoting vibrancy, and preserving character.
On Monday, October 22, the Boston Preservation Alliance hosted the 2018…
Opening Remarks: Chris Scoville, Board Chair
Preservation Achievement Awards and 40 30 10 Celebration
To celebrate our 40th Anniversary year, the Alliance launched a special social media campaign: The Preservation Bucket List photo competition.
This year marks the 40th Anniversary of the Alliance, the 30th Anniversary of the Awards, and the 10th Anniversary of our Young Advisors Board.
Join the Alliance Young Advisors for a stroll through Mount Auburn Cemetery, the oldest rural cemetery in the US.
The debate over the future of the Citgo sign is still quietly grinding on.
The debate over the future of the Citgo sign is still quietly grinding on.
Boston has an estimated $20 million in annual funds to support capital projects in historic preservation, affordable housing, and parks and green spaces.
Developer Related Beal on Tuesday went before the Boston Civic Design Commission to submit its updated plans to redevelop buildings on Commonwealth Avenue near Deerfield Street.
Developer Related Beal on Tuesday went before the Boston Civic Design Commission to submit its updated plans to redevelop buildings on Commonwealth Avenue near Deerfield Street.
Developer Related Beal on Tuesday went before the Boston Civic Design Commission to submit its updated plans to redevelop buildings on Commonwealth Avenue near Deerfield Street.
Boston’s urban planners and placemakers have an opportunity to make the Northern Avenue Bridge, now a rusting relic in Fort Point Channel, a postcard-worthy destination that draws…
It has been nearly four years since anyone could walk across the old Northern Avenue Bridge, and two decades since you could drive across it.
The Boston Preservation Alliance was included in a 2018 national report regarding best practices for public outreach and education to build a knowledgeable, engaged, and activated…
As neighborhoods change over generations, it’s important that touchpoints to their past both remain in place and sensitively evolve to maintain their relevance.
As neighborhoods change over generations, it’s important that touchpoints to their past both remain in place and sensitively evolve to maintain their relevance.
As neighborhoods change over generations, it’s important that touchpoints to their past both remain in place and sensitively evolve to maintain their relevance.
As neighborhoods change over generations, it’s important that touchpoints to their past both remain in place and sensitively evolve to maintain their relevance.
As neighborhoods change over generations, it’s important that touchpoints to their past both remain in place and sensitively evolve to maintain their relevance.
As neighborhoods change over generations, it’s important that touchpoints to their past both remain in place and sensitively evolve to maintain their relevance.
Boston was once home to 31 breweries, enough to bestow this storied city with the title of “most breweries per capita.” A majority of the city’s breweries are clustered around…
The Boston Preservation Alliance offers internships to graduate and undergraduate students to help train the next generation of preservationists by providing hands-on experience in the…
Boston City Council voted on Thursday, June 21, to approve the first batch of Boston Community Preservation funding requests.
Boston City Council voted on Thursday, June 21, to approve the first batch of Boston Community Preservation funding requests.
You’re invited to a special preview for Alliance and Boston By Foot members. The Ladder Blocks Walking Tour will take place on Sunday, May 20, from 2:00 to 3:30 p.m.
Boston has a wonderful mix of historic buildings and sites, from stately row houses to 3-deckers, churches to commercial blocks.
The Young Advisors of the Boston Preservation Alliance are hosting a PechaKucha night on Tuesday, May 15 at The Algonquin Club of Boston.
The Alliance had an impressive showing at Preservation Massachusetts’s 30th Annual Paul & Niki Tsongas Awards Dinner held on May 9 at the Fairmont Copley Plaza Hotel in Boston.
May is Preservation Month. To mark the occasion, Boston Architecture Diary tapped Greg Galer to share recommendations for preservation events happening around the city.
Alliance Executive Director Greg Galer was a moderator for “Preserving Affordability, Affording Preservation,” an April 27th conference hosted by Historic New England.
The Boston Preservation Alliance is pleased to announce the appointment of Chris Scoville as a new Board Chairman and the election of Sean Geary to the Board of Directors.
The Boston Preservation Alliance is hosting its Annual Meeting on Wednesday, March 21 at historic Old South Church at Copley Square.
From old fire departments to post offices that succumbed to the demise of snail mail, buildings across the country have fallen prey to shifting markets and the rise of technology.