Density Done Right: Examples from Boston and Barcelona

By David Nagahiro, AIA, LEED AP

David NagahiroDavid Nagahiro is a passionate leader and advocate for the arts, architecture and historic preservation in Boston and beyond. With more than 30 years of experience in the field, he has dedicated himself and his work to bettering the communities in which he works through thoughtful and forward-thinking design. He is a principal at CBT and a proud board member of both Artists for Humanity and the Boston Preservation Alliance.

Density Drives Great Design

Many people are surprised to find that density and preservation can, in fact, work together. Indeed, they’ve been doing so for hundreds of years.

One of the easiest places to see this is in Europe. The reason so many people love to visit Europe is the energy of its streets, the beauty of its buildings, and the diversity of its peoples. These things simply aren’t possible without density.

That being said, it is easy to be intimidated by the idea of density. Density shouldn’t be something that covers up the past, but instead something that brings the past into the present— and even into the future.

As a principal at CBT, a Boston-based architecture firm founded on the principles of historic preservation in 1967, and a proud board member of the Boston Preservation Alliance, I’m saddened to see density so often associated with poor design. Density is not the enemy. To the contrary, I believe that density (done right) drives great design.

Here are two examples that have inspired me to strive for both density and great design here in Boston. The first comes from our own hometown. The second comes from our European sister city— Barcelona.

Atlantic Wharf

Atlantic Wharf
Boston, MA

Completed in 2011, this 1.2 million square foot adaptive reuse project was the first LEED Platinum high rise in Boston.

This landmark project perches a sleek glass tower on top of three beautifully preserved and restored historic buildings. These include the seven-story limestone Peabody & Stearns Atlantic Building on the northwest corner of the site as well as two brick industrial buildings closer to Fort Point Channel. Today, these historic buildings house retail, commercial and residential uses.

Complete with a green roof and waterfront park, this human-scaled, historically sensitive skyscraper has been widely recognized for its sustainability, design and preservation excellence. A win-win-win for the development, preservation and local communities, Atlantic Wharf is living proof that density and great design can go hand-in-hand right here in Boston.

Atlantic Wharf in the 1900s.
Atlantic Wharf in the 1900s.
Atlantic Wharf today.
Atlantic Wharf today.

Barcelona

1992 Olympic Games
Barcelona, Spain

The 1992 Olympic and Paralympic Games brought an incredible amount of new life to Barcelona, and with it density (the good kind). With the Games as a catalyst, Barcelona embraced density to modernize and reinvent itself and its previously industrial waterfront—all while maintaining its historic significance. 

Torre Agbar

Spain
Barcelona beautifully blends modernity and history.

This suggests that through good urban planning our communities can continue to grow and thrive, adapt and evolve, and even change, while preserving the historic qualities that make them unique. Barcelona’s growth is an especially great example for Boston, as the two cities are so similar.

Barcelona
Barcelona
Boston
Boston

Boston and Barcelona are both beautiful, historic and walkable waterfront cities. They are also both cities with great sports cultures and global influence. They are even (more or less) the same size in terms of land area. Surprisingly, though, Barcelona is three times as dense as Boston!

While Boston is home to 650,000 people, Barcelona is home to 1,750,000 people. This amazingly vital city is also home to a vibrant public realm, a robust and well-connected transit system and a deep history.

Typical Barcelona block structure
Typical Barcelona block structure

Barcelona’s famous (at least among planners) block structures create density not with towers, but with culturally and historically sensitive mid-rise buildings centered on community courtyards. Chamfered corners, generous sidewalks, grand boulevards and welcoming plazas create an active public realm amidst the city’s human-scaled buildings. Finally, the city welcomes the new among the old, beautifully blending modern and historic styles.

Since hosting the Games and opening its hearts and minds to both density and great design, Barcelona has become one of the most visited and highly thriving cities not just in Europe, but in the world!

What’s the Take-Away?

Boston

By 2050, it is predicted that approximately two thirds of the world’s population will live in cities. In order to remain relevant, Boston will have to grow. And, as Barcelona proves, we have room to grow in a way that both respects and celebrates our rich history.

Recent

Preservation Achievement Awards & 40 30 10 Celebration

This year marks the 40th Anniversary of the Alliance, the 30th Anniversary of the Awards, and the 10th Anniversary of our Young Advisors Board.

EVENT: Tour of Mount Auburn Cemetery

Join the Alliance Young Advisors for a stroll through Mount Auburn Cemetery, the oldest rural cemetery in the US.

The Preservation Bucket List + Photo Competition

The Alliance is turning 40 this year!

September 7: Deadline for eligibility forms for Fall 2018 Community Preservation Funds

Boston has an estimated $20 million in annual funds to support capital projects in historic preservation, affordable housing, and parks and green spaces.

SOLD OUT! Libations for Preservation

Thank you for your overwhelming interest and support for preservation in Boston! This event is sold out.

Citgo sign here to stay, but maybe not surrounding buildings

Developer Related Beal on Tuesday went before the Boston Civic Design Commission to submit its updated plans to redevelop buildings on Commonwealth Avenue near Deerfield Street.

Citgo sign here to stay, but maybe not surrounding buildings

Developer Related Beal on Tuesday went before the Boston Civic Design Commission to submit its updated plans to redevelop buildings on Commonwealth Avenue near Deerfield Street.

Citgo sign here to stay, but maybe not surrounding buildings

Developer Related Beal on Tuesday went before the Boston Civic Design Commission to submit its updated plans to redevelop buildings on Commonwealth Avenue near Deerfield Street.

Boston, here's the chance to make Northern Avenue Bridge a real destination

Boston's urban planners and placemakers have an opportunity to make the Northern Avenue Bridge, now a rusting relic in Fort Point Channel, a postcard-worthy destination that draws in…

The Northern Avenue Bridge is being replaced, and the city is debating just who will be allowed to use it

It has been nearly four years since anyone could walk across the old Northern Avenue Bridge, and two decades since you could drive across it.

Alliance Included in National Best Practices Report

The Boston Preservation Alliance was included in a 2018 national report regarding best practices for public outreach and education to build a knowledgeable, engaged, and activated…

Defending Fenway’s Heritage

Emily Kahn, Boston Preservation Alliance Intern

Defending Fenway’s Heritage

Emily Kahn, Boston Preservation Alliance Intern

Announcing the 2018 Preservation Achievement Award winners!

As neighborhoods change over generations, it's important that touchpoints to their past both remain in place and sensitively evolve to maintain their relevance.

Announcing the 2018 Preservation Achievement Award winners!

As neighborhoods change over generations, it's important that touchpoints to their past both remain in place and sensitively evolve to maintain their relevance.

Announcing the 2018 Preservation Achievement Award winners!

As neighborhoods change over generations, it's important that touchpoints to their past both remain in place and sensitively evolve to maintain their relevance.

Announcing the 2018 Preservation Achievement Award winners!

As neighborhoods change over generations, it's important that touchpoints to their past both remain in place and sensitively evolve to maintain their relevance.

Announcing the 2018 Preservation Achievement Award winners!

As neighborhoods change over generations, it's important that touchpoints to their past both remain in place and sensitively evolve to maintain their relevance.

Announcing the 2018 Preservation Achievement Award winners!

As neighborhoods change over generations, it's important that touchpoints to their past both remain in place and sensitively evolve to maintain their relevance.

EVENT: Instagram Tour: Historic Breweries of Jamaica Plain

Boston was once home to 31 breweries, enough to bestow this storied city with the title of "most breweries per capita." A majority of the city's breweries are clustered around Stony…

Meet Our 2018 Summer Interns

The Boston Preservation Alliance offers internships to graduate and undergraduate students to help train the next generation of preservationists by providing hands-on experience in the…

City Council Awards First Batch of Boston Community Preservation Funds

Boston City Council voted on Thursday, June 21, to approve the first batch of Boston Community Preservation funding requests.

City Council Awards First Batch of Boston Community Preservation Funds

Boston City Council voted on Thursday, June 21, to approve the first batch of Boston Community Preservation funding requests.

EVENT: Ladder Blocks Walking Tour

You’re invited to a special preview for Alliance and Boston By Foot members. The Ladder Blocks Walking Tour will take place on Sunday, May 20, from 2:00 to 3:30 p.m.

EVENT: Preservation in Perpetuity: An Overview of Preservation Restrictions

Boston has a wonderful mix of historic buildings and sites, from stately row houses to 3-deckers, churches to commercial blocks.

EVENT: Preservation, Powered by PechaKucha

The Young Advisors of the Boston Preservation Alliance are hosting a PechaKucha night on Tuesday, May 15 at The Algonquin Club of Boston.

Director of Advocacy, Alison Frazee, recognized with highest honor at 2018 Tsongas Awards

The Alliance had an impressive showing at Preservation Massachusetts’s 30th Annual Paul & Niki Tsongas Awards Dinner held on May 9 at the Fairmont Copley Plaza Hotel in Boston.

Alliance ED Guest Editor of Boston Architecture Diary

May is Preservation Month. To mark the occasion, Boston Architecture Diary tapped Greg Galer to share recommendations for preservation events happening around the city.

Does the three-decker have lessons for us today? 

Alliance Executive Director Greg Galer was a moderator for "Preserving Affordability, Affording Preservation," an April 27th conference hosted by Historic New England.

The Alliance Appoints New Board Chair and Elects New Board Member

The Boston Preservation Alliance is pleased to announce the appointment of Chris Scoville as a new Board Chairman and the election of Sean Geary to the Board of Directors.

Alliance Celebrates 40 years, Looks Forward at 2018 Annual Meeting

The Boston Preservation Alliance is hosting its Annual Meeting on Wednesday, March 21 at historic Old South Church at Copley Square.

7 Buildings Living Their Best Second Lives

From old fire departments to post offices that succumbed to the demise of snail mail, buildings across the country have fallen prey to shifting markets and the rise of technology.

Paramount Theatre and the Boston Opera House Honored For Their Remarkable Makeovers

Last week, the National Trust for Historic Preservation

Thank you to all our corporate members, including: