A Short History of Boston’s Triple Deckers
A Short History of Boston’s Triple Deckers
Between 1880 and 1930, an estimated 15,000 triple-deckers (also called three-deckers) were built in Boston and surrounding cities. Supplying the housing needs of huge numbers of new immigrants, and Black, working, and middle-class families, the triple-decker offered a path to homeownership, generated income for families who could both live and rent the same house and accommodated multigenerational family living.
The origin of the triple-decker is unknown. A common mythology suggests that a builder lacking the funds to finish a two-family Victoria home finished the structure by adding a flat roof instead of a Mansard roof. However, this is a moot point as the oldest known triple-deckers are largely mansard roofed with decks behind.
Other variations of the same story suggest a builder built a third story taller than first intended, and ultimately modified the structure, creating a usable third floor. The term itself ‘triple-decker,’ is believed to have been borrowed from a 1637 British man-of-war ship called the “Sovereign of the Seas,” which boasted three decks of guns above the waterline.
In 1914, sociologists Robert Woods and Albert Kennedy wrote:
The values which the tenant receives in this modern flat are so little short of luxurious that it is no wonder they are in demand. A flat which rents for from 20 to 25 dollars a month includes a parlor, dining room, kitchen with set tubs, cook stove with gas stove and water heater attached, two bedrooms, front and back piazza, hot air furnace, electricity and hardwood floors…
Apart from the economic value of the triple-decker, they also provided a small form of what Jane Jacobs would later call “eyes on the street.” Knowing that the house was full all the time was reassuring, “even if I don’t know them very well,” remarked one woman in a 1917 interview with the Worcester Planning Board.
Triple-deckers are simple structures; think of a free-standing building containing three narrow apartments stacked on top of each other. Internally, rooms like kitchens and bathrooms are usually kept directly above each other. This allows for an energy-efficient arrangement as it keeps electricity and plumbing in one direct line from top to bottom, and gives each apartment access to windows and natural light on all four sides. Arthur Krim of the Boston Redevelopment Authority wrote in 1977 that as an architecture, triple-deckers “are curious forms, part urban and part suburban. They look like apartments transformed into houses, or perhaps houses overgrown into apartments.” Their ambiguity feels a large part of their allure. Whether one treats them as a set of apartments or as their own row house, their communal quality allows this strange form to coalesce as a unit.
The New Haven Preservation Trust notes that beyond these general characteristics, they “display a broad range of variations… some have gable roofs, others have gambrel roofs; some have projecting window bays, others do not; some have 3-story porches… some are built of brick, others of concrete block; some are paired versions…sharing a common bearing wall.” In Boston, nearly all non-modern triple deckers are built of wood in a simple wood-frame style. Krim suggests that the usage of wood both originates from Colonial wood building technology and also connected Boston’s landmarks — such as the Paul Revere House — to the ongoing evolution of housing architecture.
As with all buildings, triple-deckers reflected the architectural taste of their time. Functionally between tenements and apartments, triple-deckers didn’t skimp on porches — their great innovation between the two typologies — and they developed both ahead of (and later along with) electric trolley lines that connected neighborhoods like Mattapan, Roxbury, and Dorchester.
Queen Anne Triple Decker in Worcester, MA by Brian Vanden Brink.
The earlier Queen Anne or Victorian style (1880s — mid19890s/1900) included decorative elements such as textures made with clapboards and shingles, and the occasional mansard, or sloped, roof. These triple-deckers tended to have full-height rear porches, and builders used patterned shingles and added iron crested towers. Small details like this helped individual builders distinguish and elaborate from house to house while the typology of the triple-decker was still evolving. During the Victorian period, gable and hip roofs developed, and eventually gave way to the Colonial Revival style. Colonial Revival Style had already been popular for other home types because they easily blended into the visual streetscape of Victorian Era Boston.
Taft Street, Dorchester. Photo by Matthew Dickey.
The Colonial Revival (mid-1890s/1900 — 1920s) is more austere than Queen Anne. The earlier triple-deckers of this style developed the two-story front porch which allowed families living on the second and third floors to have their own private balcony. The Colonial style used more uniform exterior sidings, which removed decorative textures, and plain columns and posts replaced the ornamented balusters and posts of the Queen Anne style, adding rounded bays. Elegant cornices, curved glass, and rounded bays became a feature of the more expensive triple-deckers, and the six-family house (two triple-deckers joined together, usually by a central staircase), came into fashion as well.
In the 1920s and later, triple-deckers began featuring a combination of elements from both styles, emphasizing functionality more than ornamentation.
Krim observes that Boston had two types of three-deckers due to different builders in each area. South Boston’s triple-deckers were mostly flat-roofed, Roxbury’s roofs were pitched, and Dorchester had a combination of both styles. Dorchester was a ‘street-car suburb’ of Boston, so housing developed adjacent to and with the expansion of the streetcar system. Krim writes that the streetcar and the triple-decker “had been perfected” in 1890, the year they collided in Dorchester.
As the triple-decker provided affordable housing for mostly immigrants and Black residents, this turned it into the central target for nationally-organized housing ‘reform advocates.’ These ‘advocates,’ all of whom held racist and xenophobic views rallied against the “triple-decker menace,” as described in a 1917 article published in Providence Magazine.
Small things such as code changes led to outright bans, and so, the eventual demise of new triple-decker construction. For example, the 1912 Town Tenement Act allowed Massachusetts municipalities to ban wood-frame structures where cooking was performed above the second floor. Most triple-deckers were wood-framed in the Boston area. And so, individuals like Prescott Farnsworth Hall — founder of the Immigration Restriction League and active housing reformer — became ‘fire hazards,’ even though Woods and Kennedy discredited this claim, observing that “with stairways and piazzas on two ends of the house, it would be practically impossible for people to be burned alive—and thus far losses of life in three-decker fires have been infinitesimal.”
By the 1920s, 36 municipalities in Massachusetts — including Arlington, Belmont, Brookline, and Swampscott — had banned triple-deckers, and by the 1930s, triple-decker construction had all but stopped. Some survived through World War II while others were bulldozed in the 1950s and 1960s as part of ‘urban renewal’ efforts; there are still a few empty plots in Boston bearing witness to where these houses were. However, many triple-deckers have survived and continue to be the primary housing stock for Bostonians.
Boston’s housing shortage is legendary at this point — and recently, triple-deckers have retaken the spotlight in conversations surrounding the creation of affordable housing in Boston. Historic housing stock tends to be more affordable to begin with, and triple-deckers are retrofittable with clean energy alternatives, as Bloomberg, The Boston Globe, WBUR (and others) have written. The City of Boston’s Mayor’s Housing Innovation Lab even launched the ‘Co-Creating Boston’s Future-Decker’ project in 2021. Other attempts to create more high-density housing include Governor Charlie Baker’s 2022 “MBTA Communities Bill” requiring 175 municipalities served by the T to build denser housing near a station, an action that anticipates thousands of apartments and condos.
All neighborhoods continue to bear the scars of Boston’s architectural past and so, of Boston’s social legacy. While it’s critical to continue building housing to accommodate a growing city population and make it affordable to live here, these modern structures lack a unique city character. Balancing development with aesthetics is important — and not simply for the sake of vanity, but for the sake of identity. Whether that identity needs to be reclaimed, recreated, or repurposed, it’s the triple-decker that gives us a window into the intersection of past and future: creating affordable, multi-density, and multigenerational housing while maintaining a distinctive sense of place.
Sources:
- Triple-deckers were once an affordable solution to Boston’s housing crunch — and can be again, Greg Minott, Boston Globe, 2021.
- Rediscovering the three-decker house, Howard Husock, Public interest, 1990.
- What happened to the three-decker?, Jacob Wegman, MIT Department of Urban Studies and Planning, 2006.
- Sovereign of the Seas(1637); Warship; 100 guns, Royal Museums Greenwich.
- Rediscovering the three-decker house, Howard Husock.
- Three-deckers of Dorchester: an architectural historical survey, Arthur Krim, Boston Redevelopment Authority, 1977.
- TRIPLE DECKERS, New Haven Preservation Trust, 1985.
- Three-deckers of Dorchester, Arthur Krim.
- Three-deckers of Dorchester, Arthur Krim.
- Three Cheers for the Triple-Decker, Boston’s Iconic Cheap Housing, Anthony Flint, Bloomberg, 2023.
- Ep. 19: The Triple Decker Menace, Alex Nunes, The Publics Radio, 2019.
- 1912 Chap. 0635. An Act Relative To Tenement Houses In Towns, Boston: Secretary of the Commonwealth, 1912.
- Rediscovering the three-decker house, Howard Husock.
- Greater Boston Housing Earns “Failing Grade” in Annual Report Card, Molly Callahan, BU Today, 2022.
- REQUEST FOR IDEAS: Co-creating Boston’s Future Decker, City of Boston Mayor’s Housing Innovation Lab, 2021.
Recent
There was a newspaper clipping tacked to the wall in our office when I first joined the Alliance in 2013.
In partnership with the Dorchester Historical Society and Comfort Kitchen.
When: Sunday, October 20, 2024
Time: 2:30pm - 6:00pm
The City of Boston, with strong support from the Wu Administration, is advancing a proposal to…
Boston Preservation Alliance Presents their 36th Annual Achievement Award Recipients
Welcome to the third Alison About Boston blog post! I am the Executive Director of the Boston Preservation Alliance, which means that I wear many hats including leading our advocacy…
Welcome to the second Alison About Boston blog post! I am the Executive Director of the Boston Preservation Alliance, which means that I wear many hats including leading our advocacy…
When: May 9
Time: 4:30-6:00pm
Meeting Point: The Grain Exchange Building, 177 Milk Street
Register by emailing mdickey@bostonpreservation.org.
Welcome to the first Alison About Boston blog post! I am the Executive Director of the Boston Preservation Alliance, which means that I wear many hats including leading our advocacy…
May is National Preservation Month, giving us a perfect excuse to show off our beloved historic city.
Several new Landmarks have been designated in Boston. Even more are pending approval and awaiting community feedback and support.
“Love is showing the important things that they matter.” A Landmark Love quote from the Frederick Middle School.
Update: February 29, 2024
The Boston Preservation Alliance has submitted a letter to the Wu Administration.
Each year the Boston Preservation Alliance presents the Preservation Achievement Awards to recognize a group of exemplary historic preservation projects or activities in Boston.
A Visual Guide to “Barbitecture” and Real-life Doll Houses
Written by: Sara Brown
Alliance Executive Director Alison Frazee received a call last night from Mike Firestone, the City’s Chief of Policy, informing her that the Landmarks Commission has been…
May is National Preservation Month which gives us a perfect excuse to show off our beloved historic city.
May is National Preservation Month which gives us a perfect excuse to show off our beloved historic city.
On behalf of the Boston Preservation Alliance and Boston’s preservation community, we would like to thank Councilor Kenzie Bok for her dedication to our city’s historic resources.
The Codman Award for lifetime achievement, named for John Codman who established Boston’s first historic district (Beacon Hill) in 1955, recognizes outstanding and career-long…
Thank you for helping us redefine preservation. Architecture is the surface of a city, but our history is deeper than a facade. It is the people, residents, and visitors that make Boston…
The leaves have been shaken off the trees, there is a chill in the air, and the sun sets just after 4 pm–that’s right, it’s nearly winter in New England and the gift-giving…
Written by Anan Shen. This is the first of a series of short stories about the West End.
As an advocacy organization for historic preservation, the Alliance often advocates to save historic buildings because of their stunning architecture or articulated streetscape.
Written and researched by Dan Bailey.
All photos by Dan Bailey and Matthew Dickey.
Stories about our neighborhoods are often told by adults for adults. But what landmarks and businesses define our neighborhoods through the eyes of the next generation?
Thousands and thousands of buildings line Boston’s streets. But one house is different from all the rest. It takes a bit of determination to find it.
Photos by Peter Vanderwarker.
A Weekend Photo Workshop with Peter Vanderwarker, Sept. 16-18
May is National Preservation Month which gives us a perfect excuse to show off our beloved historic city.
On May 1, 2022, Boston celebrated the 200th anniversary of incorporation as a city at the Old South Meeting House.
Valentine’s Day is approaching and that means only one thing—it’s time to dust off those markers and share some love (Heart Bombs) for old buildings! What are heart bombs?
In a little triangle just south of Andrew Station, Polish and American flags fly in pairs. The air wafts with the smell of freshly fried dough.
Our Most-Watched Advocacy Projects of 2021 Are Below, But First…
The Alliance relies on generous supporters like you to continue our work in promoting, preserving,…
The Alliance has been utilizing every opportunity to further our goals of historic preservation advocacy and telling the fuller story of Boston’s past. Below are a few of our 2021…
Thursday, December 2, 10:00-11:00 am.
The Boston Preservation Alliance is Boston’s primary, non-profit advocacy organization that protects and promotes the use of historic buildings and landscapes in all of Boston’s…
Turn on your favorite sea shanty and prepare for the water. The Young Advisors are bringing their annual Libations for Preservation event to the sea!
Written by Ava Yokanovich
Photos by Ava Yokanovich
Interview with Angela Ward Hyatt
Photos courtesy of Angela Ward Hyatt
Before and after photos below!
Memories from former South End residents Judith Nee and Isabel O’Hara
Images from Neil Kadey and Judith Nee
Written by Judith Nee and Ava Yokanovich
Written by Mackenzie Barrall and Corinne Muller. Photos by Matthew Dickey.
Originally published July 2020. Updated July 2021.
The Alliance works closely with the Boston Landmarks Commission (BLC), which resides within the Environment Department at the City, to further preservation efforts in Boston.
Written by Mackenzie Barrall
Photos by Ava Yokanovich
Written by Ava Yokanovich
Images taken by Ava Yokanovich along the Southwest Corridor Path near Titus Sparrow Park
Since 1988, the National Trust has used its list of America’s 11 Most Endangered Historic Places…
Since 1988, the National Trust has used its list of America’s 11 Most Endangered Historic Places…
Since 1988, the National Trust has used its list of America’s 11 Most Endangered Historic Places…
Written by Jeanne Pelletier, Preservation Advisor to the Campaign for the Ayer Mansion, Inc.
There are untold stories in Boston being lost and we need your help to save them.
Save-The-Date
When: March 25
Time: 6 pm via Zoom
Featuring: Brent Leggs
This event is generously supported by the Nolan-Miller Fund
Corita Kent (1918–1986)
Artist, Educator, Advocate for Social Justice
Written by: Vicki Adjami
When: March 4
Time: 10 AM
Where: On Zoom
How: Register below to receive a zoom link
The Boston Preservation Alliance and the Young Advisors present:
Preservation Chatter 2020
Thursday, November 19
6 — 7 PM
David Rodrigues is the Manager of Facilities and Preservation at
Preservation takes many forms and requires many hands.
Boston Preservation Alliance stands united with the voices decrying the murder of George Floyd and the long-standing history of racism this tragedy demonstrates.
The Boston Preservation Alliance offers internships to graduate and undergraduate students to help train the next generation of preservationists by providing hands-on experience in…
Let’s come together to create a wave of generosity for the organizations that help Boston thrive.
Have a preservation question? Want to hear updates about any of the preservation projects we’re monitoring?
An Environment Notification Form (ENF) has been filed with the Massachusetts Environmental Policy Act (MEPA) Office.
May is National Preservation Month which gives us a perfect excuse to show off our beloved historic city.
Written by Alison Frazee, Assistant Director, Boston Preservation Alliance.
…Join us for our Annual Meeting of Members
When: Postponed. New date is TBD
In light of concerns with COVID-19, we have postponed several of our upcoming events.
Is there a preservationist in your life? Or maybe you love architecture, history, and unique Boston stories as much as we do. If either of these is the case, then this is THE gift guide…
With the proposed redevelopment of the Hurley Building, we thought this is a good time…
Preservation advocates are imploring Massachusetts General Hospital to reconfigure its expansion plans to avoid demolition of three historic West End buildings, reports Dan Murphy of the…
By Isabella Labbe
August 6, 2019. Updated March 2023.
The Boston Preservation Alliance Board of Young Advisors presents:
Libations for Preservation
When:
Wednesday, July 24, 2019…
Karen McFeaters is a Boston-based painter whose work features locations around the city that highlight…
Roger Webb was the founder of the Architectural Heritage Foundation and…
Save the date for Beer + Mortar, a walking tour through Dorchester and Roxbury led by Matthew Dickey of the Alliance and HBI.…
The City of Boston invites you to a Community Meeting on the Northern Ave Bridge
Monday, June 3, 2019
Neighborhoods are living things. They evolve to the changing needs of their inhabitants. Rural farms become streetcar suburbs. Carriage lanes become roads. Thriving businesses fade.
In partnership with Massachusetts Historical Society and Fenway Alliance.
The state gets a $98M cut of GE’s sale of its property in Fort Point. Where should that money go?
May is National Preservation Month which gives us a perfect excuse to show off our beloved historic city.
Advocacy needed to OPPOSE a rule change to undercut the National Register of Historic Places
Please join us for our Annual Meeting | Registration is closed, but walk-ins welcome!
Boston Design Week Event
Boston Design Week March 27-April 7 2019
The Alliance’s Young Advisor’s Board is seeking new board members for 2019!
The Boston Preservation Alliance is now accepting nominations for our 2019 Preservation Achievement Awards!
The closing of Durgin Park (1827) following upon Jacob Wirth (1868) last year reminds us that Boston’s unique character comes from more than just architecture.
“An icon of the Boston skyline was very nearly protected against the city’s current rapacious development culture- but then the mayor stepped in.”
“An icon of the Boston skyline was very nearly protected against the city’s current rapacious development culture- but then the mayor stepped in.”
Mayor Walsh, Citgo, Related Beal (the developer of the site), and Boston University release a statement:
Mayor Walsh, Citgo, Related Beal (the developer of the site), and Boston University release a statement:
The City of Boston invites you to a
Community Meeting on the Northern Ave Bridge
The Young Advisors is a board of developing professionals whose role is to expand and amplify the Alliance’s mission of protecting places, promoting vibrancy, and preserving character.
On Monday, October 22, the Boston Preservation Alliance hosted the 2018…
Opening Remarks: Chris Scoville, Board Chair
Preservation Achievement Awards and 40 30 10 Celebration
To celebrate our 40th Anniversary year, the Alliance launched a special social media campaign: The Preservation Bucket List photo competition.
This year marks the 40th Anniversary of the Alliance, the 30th Anniversary of the Awards, and the 10th Anniversary of our Young Advisors Board.
Join the Alliance Young Advisors for a stroll through Mount Auburn Cemetery, the oldest rural cemetery in the US.
The debate over the future of the Citgo sign is still quietly grinding on.
The debate over the future of the Citgo sign is still quietly grinding on.
Boston has an estimated $20 million in annual funds to support capital projects in historic preservation, affordable housing, and parks and green spaces.
Developer Related Beal on Tuesday went before the Boston Civic Design Commission to submit its updated plans to redevelop buildings on Commonwealth Avenue near Deerfield Street.
Developer Related Beal on Tuesday went before the Boston Civic Design Commission to submit its updated plans to redevelop buildings on Commonwealth Avenue near Deerfield Street.
Developer Related Beal on Tuesday went before the Boston Civic Design Commission to submit its updated plans to redevelop buildings on Commonwealth Avenue near Deerfield Street.
Boston’s urban planners and placemakers have an opportunity to make the Northern Avenue Bridge, now a rusting relic in Fort Point Channel, a postcard-worthy destination that draws…
It has been nearly four years since anyone could walk across the old Northern Avenue Bridge, and two decades since you could drive across it.
The Boston Preservation Alliance was included in a 2018 national report regarding best practices for public outreach and education to build a knowledgeable, engaged, and activated…
As neighborhoods change over generations, it’s important that touchpoints to their past both remain in place and sensitively evolve to maintain their relevance.
As neighborhoods change over generations, it’s important that touchpoints to their past both remain in place and sensitively evolve to maintain their relevance.
As neighborhoods change over generations, it’s important that touchpoints to their past both remain in place and sensitively evolve to maintain their relevance.
As neighborhoods change over generations, it’s important that touchpoints to their past both remain in place and sensitively evolve to maintain their relevance.
As neighborhoods change over generations, it’s important that touchpoints to their past both remain in place and sensitively evolve to maintain their relevance.
As neighborhoods change over generations, it’s important that touchpoints to their past both remain in place and sensitively evolve to maintain their relevance.
Boston was once home to 31 breweries, enough to bestow this storied city with the title of “most breweries per capita.” A majority of the city’s breweries are clustered around…
The Boston Preservation Alliance offers internships to graduate and undergraduate students to help train the next generation of preservationists by providing hands-on experience in the…
Boston City Council voted on Thursday, June 21, to approve the first batch of Boston Community Preservation funding requests.
Boston City Council voted on Thursday, June 21, to approve the first batch of Boston Community Preservation funding requests.
You’re invited to a special preview for Alliance and Boston By Foot members. The Ladder Blocks Walking Tour will take place on Sunday, May 20, from 2:00 to 3:30 p.m.
Boston has a wonderful mix of historic buildings and sites, from stately row houses to 3-deckers, churches to commercial blocks.
The Young Advisors of the Boston Preservation Alliance are hosting a PechaKucha night on Tuesday, May 15 at The Algonquin Club of Boston.
The Alliance had an impressive showing at Preservation Massachusetts’s 30th Annual Paul & Niki Tsongas Awards Dinner held on May 9 at the Fairmont Copley Plaza Hotel in Boston.
May is Preservation Month. To mark the occasion, Boston Architecture Diary tapped Greg Galer to share recommendations for preservation events happening around the city.
Alliance Executive Director Greg Galer was a moderator for “Preserving Affordability, Affording Preservation,” an April 27th conference hosted by Historic New England.
The Boston Preservation Alliance is pleased to announce the appointment of Chris Scoville as a new Board Chairman and the election of Sean Geary to the Board of Directors.
The Boston Preservation Alliance is hosting its Annual Meeting on Wednesday, March 21 at historic Old South Church at Copley Square.
From old fire departments to post offices that succumbed to the demise of snail mail, buildings across the country have fallen prey to shifting markets and the rise of technology.